Menus are excessively padded, how to change?

Quite some time ago a Plasma update caused all the menus of KDE apps to become in my mind a bit excessively padded out. Compare e.g. the context menu of Firefox:

to the context menu of dolphin:

Is there a simple way to make these menus more regularly sized again?

4 Likes

See bug https://bugs.kde.org/show_bug.cgi?id=512363

4 Likes

Oh, bummer. Thanks for the info though

3 Likes

And I apologize for the sudden change. But lessons have been learned :slight_smile:

4 Likes

No worries, but I do second the idea of having a more “dense” UI mode/style in general for smaller screens, to not waste so much space. For example I’ve also changed the Breeze window decoration button size to “tiny” to be more reasonable for my 1080p display. So it would be really nice to have sort of a meta-setting to make everything more tight…

Anyway, sorry for the ramble, and thanks for working on this.

6 Likes

With Union that should be possible. I really want to make it happen too, I would choose different values as well.

But Union still requires a lot of work, and that time is much better spent in Union than trying to fix our old styling system.

7 Likes

Just wanted to make it clear that this will be fixed in 6.5.4. The size is bit bigger than before, but not as big as it is now.

4 Likes

Is there any rough timeline on this? When will we get union? 6 months? 1 year? 2 years?

Hard to say.

I’d say within 6 months we should at least be already in testing phase? At least for the QtQuick part.

@ahiemstra would know better.

2 Likes

You could reinstall an older version and pin that until 6.5.4 becomes released.

There are still a lot of current laptops with screens that are only 768px in height. Such menus were difficult enough with the before-size. Unusable with the after-size.

Ideally we would allow users to change the density, but in our current theming system, it’s very time consuming to make it work nicely, and requires a lot of changes and testing.

1 Like

If it becomes practical, it will be vastly appreciated.

Oh no, this is intentional?

I haven’t updated yet, Manjaro hasn’t released the update yet. But I absolutely detest this trend of increasing padding in UI elements. Way to reverse any advantage gained by increasing resolution!

I hope the developers reconsider or at least provide users a way to adjust

1 Like

The spacing in the firt post was a bug
It will be ajustable in the future accurding to above comment Menus are excessively padded, how to change? - #12 by akselmo

I still think it’s a bit big, but it doesn’t look bad at least.

Out of curiosity, I did some side by side comparing with other context menus