I love the discussion here. But guys, don’t you think MacOS, gnome, vs code and even windows had exactly these kind of discussions in their UX meetings and come to the opposite conclusion independently?
In windows it’s obvious - the old control panels (Which they couldn’t even bother to retire…) are still with apply button, but new ones since windows 10 - are instant apply.
i would prefer instant apply only for item that are immediately obvious upon taking affect.
light/dark theme selection for instance… if i make a mistake or i don’t like the change, then i can just click again and boom, no harm done.
but for anything that might not be immediately obvious like some obscure setting or window rule, then i want to the ability to cancel those changes before they are applied.
so saying “settings” should always automatically apply elicits a hard NO from me, but i’m not opposed to the idea of certain settings having immediate effect… as long as they are obvious.
Stop right there… You can’t compare KDE to two software teams that have decided that the user’s opinion doesn’t matter.
In any case, wanting something to work like it works on an entirely different system leads to a lack of user choice, freedom, workflow habits, etc.
Maybe this setting could be implemented, but as a toggle when logging into KDE for the first time (user onboarding), and on the main System Settings page.
Could have a special dedicated setting in Settings that allows the user to systemically turn ON/OFF the whole concept of: ‘Apply Instantly’ -vs- ‘Need to additionally hit “Apply”’.
You mean that they make the UX worse?
I run KDE plasma, Windows (rarely) and macOS. I see UX improvements most of the time.
Microsoft makes a point of publishing their UX research and for bit UI changes you can often find blogs explaining why they changed stuff.
Could have a special dedicated setting in Settings that allows the user to systemically turn ON/OFF the whole concept of: ‘Apply Instantly’ -vs- ‘Need to additionally hit “Apply”’.
Does that have an Apply button ![]()

