Why won't settings automatically apply changes?

Hi guys, this topic probably been discussed several times before, so excuse me if you’re already answered it (quick search could find it, and you know what, I didn’t want to ask any GPT for it).

But I do want to know what’s the reasoning behind the decision not to apply the settings instantaneously.

It was something that bothered me sinse first time using KDE in version 4. Is it a technical reason, or somehow KDE devs decided it’s a better UX?

1 Like

I can’t tell you who decided on it, but it’s way better UX in my opinion.
Especially in settings dialogs you should never apply while the user is still looking around and changing stuff. Clicked on a wrong display resolution by accident? Oops, I guess you’ll have to wait for 15 seconds until it automatically resets and you can see again.
My favorite example is some months ago, when I needed to try a GTK application to see if the dropdowns reacted to mouse wheel (for some help thread on here). Well, the first one that came to mind was a backup application, scrolling through the dropdown worked and it instantly started a backup task. Well, thanks, definitely not what I wanted.

On the other hand, what’s so bad about one small extra click to confirm everything at once?

3 Likes

If the settings are all independent then they can be applied immediately and that is where macOS and iOS have gone.

If you have to set a group of values then that mandates an Apply button.

1 Like

I wouldn’t want Display or Monitor settings to be instant… same with keyboard settings.

But lots of things are instant - Bluetooth settings for example…

1 Like

I understand the wrong resolution example, but these examples are not as common as, for example, enabling the touchscreen, changing theme and wallpaper, enabling and disabling kwin scripts, changing mouse and trackpad speeds, changing hot keys, etc…

It’s not “bad” in the sense that it doesn’t screws the workflow, but most of the times it’s annoying, and counterintuitive, when comparing to other os’s settings. I did find myself numerous times telling myself “oh, I forgot to click apply”.
(Tht’s also the reason I didn’t mention it by now…)

1 Like

Yes, and volumes. I think there are more things that can benefit from instant apply, two examples I’ve mentioned before, any theme and color change, mouse and trackpad settings, and so on.

4 Likes

I’d personally rather get rid of all the “instant” settings, instead of having to know which ones update instantly and which ones don’t.
The sound settings page is actually one of the worst offenders - not because of the Volume per se (I can live with that), but change a dropdown by accident and suddenly you turned of your audio device and also the whole page rearranges and chances are you don’t even know which device you changed because they all have cryptic names (to a normal user). There’s no way to reset either, so have fun trying to get your sound back.

I know there’s many people who like this automatic applying, but I’d personally rather have the safety net and I’m convinced it’s the better option for a “normal” user.

6 Likes

I just double click those to apply.

Imagine if your mouse is a bit fast, and you drag the speed slider the wrong way…

I can understand the want for this change, but I’ve accidentally clicked or even scrolled settings, and it is only when trying to move from that page or close the window that I realised that I made a change.

Instant settings changes would screw some users over, as I can’t believe I’d be the only one who has accidentally done this.

5 Likes

Got it! Thanks for the answers.

See Getting input | Developer

Use a Switch for “instant apply” controls that take effect immediately. Use a CheckBox for everything else — including for toggle-able list items.

Most System Settings pages have checkboxes.

I don’t care if it’s one setting or dozens I want the final apply so I can reconsider at anytime. Rather it’s one or dozens autoapply does more easily allow for changes you don’t actually want to take place. I would never look to Apple, Android, Windows for feature ideas.

1 Like

Better control over the system.

If you introduced both autosave for minor stuff and manual saving for critical stuff, then you introduce another user error surface.

Current reminder about unsaved changes works well.

2 Likes

One is prompted to apply any changes they made or discard them.

1 Like

personally i think the need to hit apply is good since there have been plenty of times i’ve accidentally clicked something without realizing it and Don’t want to change it. having to comfirm it is a god thing imo .

that said i guess for those it bothers a toggle option for things like this could be useful tho i imagine it would add more work needlessly for something that already functions well and could add possible bug issues where they don’t exist cause of how many variables it could effect.

3 Likes

Can be good - not always, imagine if every time you turned your volume dial (sorry, can’t type kn0b in here :rofl: ) it warned you ‘are you sure?’.

But there are definitely many cases where you don’t want instant click-to-oblivion without at least offering a 30 second ‘click to accept, will revert in 30,29,28…’ or so.

1 Like

:person_facepalming:

2 Likes

i mean i get what you mean but it doesn’t do that for the volume currently where OP is refering about soo ..-ya know sorta a moot point

Agreed, volume isn’t the OP’s example. My point is narrower… bouncing off your comment.

KDE already applies many settings instantly where it’s sensible - uses other patterns where instant apply is too risky, and other patterns (revert timer for display settings).

I agree a global toggle would add maintenance and risk - a narrower option like an opt-in revert timer for some KCMs that apply instantly might be an idea worth thinking about (not sure where) for specific cases - but an all instant/all apply option is too shallow an option.

But really, unless we can think of concrete and actionable examples which might benefit from a change or another approach, the discussion’s going nowhere fast.

1 Like

:person_facepalming: